| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.64 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 153 to 153 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
This is one of those dilemmas where I don't have time to figure it all out; I'm going to have to rely on Bayesian priors and, furthermore, I am going to have to assume that I have some Bayesian priors worth listening to. | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
The one Bayesian prior I have to hope is gold in the bank is me: as far as I can tell, I owe my own recentered Verbal 790 not to anything my schools did, but to the fact that I was a bookworm. (Do people even use the term "bookworm" any more? Do bookworms still exist?) I read all the time, from age 5 on. I read whatever I wanted to read, and what I wanted to read was fiction up 'til high school when I started reading the Great Works of authors like A.S. Neill, John Holt, and Eldridge Cleaver. | |||||||
| > > |
The one Bayesian prior I have to hope is gold in the bank is me: as far as I can tell, I owe my own recentered Verbal 790 not to anything my schools did, but to the fact that I was a bookworm. (Do people even use the term "bookworm" any more? Do bookworms still exist?) I read all the time, from age 5 on. I read whatever I wanted to read, and what I wanted to read was fiction. I read fiction & only fiction up until high school when I started reading the Great Works of authors like A.S. Neill, John Holt, and Eldridge Cleaver. | |||||||
| So....I'm going to do what my mother did. | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.63 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 153 to 153 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
This is one of those dilemmas where I don't have time to figure it all out; I'm going to have to rely on Bayesian priors and, furthermore, I am going to have to assume that I have some Bayesian priors worth listening to. | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
The one Bayesian prior I have to hope is gold in the bank is me: as far as I can tell, I owe my own recentered Verbal 790 not to anything my schools did, but to the fact that I was a natural born bookworm. I read all the time, from age 5 on. I read whatever I wanted to read, and what I wanted to read was fiction up 'til high school when I started reading the Great Works of authors like A.S. Neill, John Holt, and Eldridge Cleaver. | |||||||
| > > |
The one Bayesian prior I have to hope is gold in the bank is me: as far as I can tell, I owe my own recentered Verbal 790 not to anything my schools did, but to the fact that I was a bookworm. (Do people even use the term "bookworm" any more? Do bookworms still exist?) I read all the time, from age 5 on. I read whatever I wanted to read, and what I wanted to read was fiction up 'til high school when I started reading the Great Works of authors like A.S. Neill, John Holt, and Eldridge Cleaver. | |||||||
| So....I'm going to do what my mother did. | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.62 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 122 to 122 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
So I cruised the readability stuff....and got out my book on summarizing and finally committed to reading the whole thing....and in brief, semi-lucid waking moments I was trying to figure out how, exactly, I'm going to make sure Christopher reads progressively more challenging material AND is "held accountable," by me, for his progressively more challenging reading I came across the following passage: | |||||||
| > > |
So I cruised the readability stuff....and got out my book on summarizing and finally committed to reading the whole thing....and in brief, semi-lucid waking moments I was trying to figure out how, exactly, I'm going to make sure Christopher reads progressively more challenging material AND is "held accountable," by me, for his progressively more challenging reading, I came across the following passage: | |||||||
|
| ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.61 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 122 to 122 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
So I cruised the readability stuff....and got out my book on summarizing and finally committed to reading the whole thing....and in waking moments I was trying to figure out how, exactly, I'm going to make sure Christopher reads progressively more challenging material AND is "held accountable," by me, for his progressively more challenging reading I came across the following passage: | |||||||
| > > |
So I cruised the readability stuff....and got out my book on summarizing and finally committed to reading the whole thing....and in brief, semi-lucid waking moments I was trying to figure out how, exactly, I'm going to make sure Christopher reads progressively more challenging material AND is "held accountable," by me, for his progressively more challenging reading I came across the following passage: | |||||||
|
| ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.60 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 116 to 116 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The San Diego Quick Assessment is a dandy tool, I think. | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
I gave it to Christopher and discovered that his "reading for pleasure" level is grade 6; his "instructional" level is grade 7. I suspect he's going to come out higher than that on the ITBS, but the San Diego was helpful. The two words Christopher couldn't read were science vocabulary: "relativity" (grade 6) and "capillary" (grade 7). | |||||||
| > > |
I gave it to Christopher and discovered that his "reading for pleasure" level is grade 6; his "instructional" level is grade 7. I suspect he's going to come out higher than that on the ITBS, but the San Diego was helpful. The two words Christopher couldn't read both belong to science vocabulary, which I think is probably good:** "relativity" (grade 6) and "capillary" (grade 7). | |||||||
|
If you're going to use it with your own child, use this link. | ||||||||
| Line: 197 to 197 | ||||||||
|
Elaine McEwan website * The quest for rescue-by-parochial-school has begun early this year. | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
||||||||
| > > |
** "good" because I suspect that science vocabulary is the least important language Christopher needs at this point and even down the line....and because Christopher has had two quite good science teachers so far in middle school. I think he's getting what he needs there - or getting as much as he can. | |||||||
|
| ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.59 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 102 to 102 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| That made sense, but what's a more complicated book? | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
How do I find out? | |||||||
| > > |
How complicated are the books C. is reading now? And how do I find out? | |||||||
|
This question led to lots of cruising of readability websites & white papers..... | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.58 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.57 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 98 to 98 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| I haven't finished reading that chapter, but Elaine said she was depressed by the research on this, so naturally I became depressed, too. Being sick in bed with the flu helped. | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
Elaine (apparently we're on a first name basis, Elaine & me) thinks students have to be "held accountable" for their reading - i.e. they have to do something, such as writing a summary, to show they not only read a book or two, they understood what they read - and they have to read more complicated books this year than they did last year and the year before. | |||||||
| > > |
Elaine (apparently we're on a first name basis, Elaine & me) thinks students have to be "held accountable" for their reading - i.e. they have to do something, such as writing a summary, to show they not only read a book or two, they understood what they read. And they have to read more complicated books this year than they did last year and the year before. | |||||||
| That made sense, but what's a more complicated book? | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.56 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 84 to 84 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Alright, enough of that.* | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
As I was saying, I'm trying to figure out | |||||||
| > > |
As I was saying, I'm trying to figure out | |||||||
| Over the weekend, this seemed to mean cruising reading comprehension websites..... | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.55 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 6 to 6 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
Now that we have across-the-board | |||||||
| > > |
Now that we have across-the-board | |||||||
| The "challenge" here in Irvington is that we have a spiral curriculum in math and ELA classes that assign novels two years below grade level. This results in predictable not-great achievement by the end of middle school, at which point we throw the kids into ferocious competition and tracking for accelerated and Honors classes. | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.54 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 192 to 192 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| ||||||||
| Added: | ||||||||
| > > |
Elaine McEwan website | |||||||
|
* The quest for rescue-by-parochial-school has begun early this year.
| ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.53 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 98 to 98 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| I haven't finished reading that chapter, but Elaine said she was depressed by the research on this, so naturally I became depressed, too. Being sick in bed with the flu helped. | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
Elaine (apparently we're on a first name basis, Elaine & me) thinks students have to be "held accountable" for their reading - i.e. they have to do something, such as writing a summary, to show they not only read a book or two, they understood what they read - and they have to read more complicated books this year than they did last year and the year before. | |||||||
| > > |
Elaine (apparently we're on a first name basis, Elaine & me) thinks students have to be "held accountable" for their reading - i.e. they have to do something, such as writing a summary, to show they not only read a book or two, they understood what they read - and they have to read more complicated books this year than they did last year and the year before. | |||||||
| That made sense, but what's a more complicated book? | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.52 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 98 to 98 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| I haven't finished reading that chapter, but Elaine said she was depressed by the research on this, so naturally I became depressed, too. Being sick in bed with the flu helped. | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
Elaine (apparently we're on a first name basis, Elaine & me) thinks students have to be "held accountable" for their reading - i.e. they have to do something, such as writing a summary, to show they not only read the thing, they understood it - and they have to continually read more complicated books. | |||||||
| > > |
Elaine (apparently we're on a first name basis, Elaine & me) thinks students have to be "held accountable" for their reading - i.e. they have to do something, such as writing a summary, to show they not only read a book or two, they understood what they read - and they have to read more complicated books this year than they did last year and the year before. | |||||||
| That made sense, but what's a more complicated book? | ||||||||
| Added: | ||||||||
| > > |
How do I find out? | |||||||
|
This question led to lots of cruising of readability websites & white papers..... | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.51 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 98 to 98 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| I haven't finished reading that chapter, but Elaine said she was depressed by the research on this, so naturally I became depressed, too. Being sick in bed with the flu helped. | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
Elaine (apparently we're on a first name basis these days, Elaine & me) thinks students have to be "held accountable" for their reading - i.e. they have to do something, such as writing a summary, to show they not only read the thing, they understood it - and they have to continually read more complicated books. | |||||||
| > > |
Elaine (apparently we're on a first name basis, Elaine & me) thinks students have to be "held accountable" for their reading - i.e. they have to do something, such as writing a summary, to show they not only read the thing, they understood it - and they have to continually read more complicated books. | |||||||
| That made sense, but what's a more complicated book? | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.50 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 98 to 98 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| I haven't finished reading that chapter, but Elaine said she was depressed by the research on this, so naturally I became depressed, too. Being sick in bed with the flu helped. | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
Elaine (we're on a first name basis at this point, Elaine & me) thinks students have to be "held accountable" for their reading - i.e. they have to do something, such as writing a summary, to show they not only read the thing, they understood it - and they have to continually read more complicated books. | |||||||
| > > |
Elaine (apparently we're on a first name basis these days, Elaine & me) thinks students have to be "held accountable" for their reading - i.e. they have to do something, such as writing a summary, to show they not only read the thing, they understood it - and they have to continually read more complicated books. | |||||||
| That made sense, but what's a more complicated book? | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.49 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 92 to 92 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| oh! | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
I know. | |||||||
| > > |
I remember. | |||||||
| Elaine McEwan's book Raising Reading Achievement in Middle and High Schools: Five Simple-to-Follow Strategies arrived with depressing news: just having your kids read books doesn't seem to be enough. | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.48 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 86 to 86 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
As I was saying, I'm trying to figure out | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
This meant cruising reading comprehension websites.....I don't even know what got me going on that, but there you are. | |||||||
| > > |
Over the weekend, this seemed to mean cruising reading comprehension websites..... I don't even know what got me going on that, but there you are. | |||||||
| oh! | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.47 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 26 to 26 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Last year an Irvington administrator told me that "Irvington is the most heavily tracked district I've ever seen." | ||||||||
| Added: | ||||||||
| > > |
Direct quote. | |||||||
| So that's the dilemma. We're paying $20,000 a year in property taxes for Darwinian gatekeeping. | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.46 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 159 to 159 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| If the school told Christopher he had to read X number of books this year, he'd read X number of books. | ||||||||
| Added: | ||||||||
| > > |
Unfortunately, the school's reading plan for 7th graders appears to consist of....two books? Three? Well, maybe it's four. Maybe they read one book a quarter. I don't know. Parents never know! | |||||||
|
I think Ed and I are going to figure out a whole new plan.... | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.45 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 164 to 164 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
Meanwhile I continue to feel that Vocabulary Workshop is an excellent work-around for non-bookworm boy-type kids. | |||||||
| > > |
Meanwhile I continue to feel that Vocabulary Workshop is an excellent work-around for non-bookworm boy-type kids. | |||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.44 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 155 to 155 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
I may also try to bribe the school into giving him an assigned reading list filled with books at his actual reading level. | ||||||||
| Added: | ||||||||
| > > |
The difference between Christopher and me is PlayStation and pro wrestling.
If the school told Christopher he had to read X number of books this year, he'd read X number of books.
I think Ed and I are going to figure out a whole new plan.... Meanwhile I continue to feel that Vocabulary Workshop is an excellent work-around for non-bookworm boy-type kids. | |||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.43 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 165 to 165 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
* The quest for rescue-by-parochial-school has begun early this year. | |||||||
| > > |
* The quest for rescue-by-parochial-school has begun early this year. | |||||||
|
| ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.42 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 80 to 80 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
Alright, enough of that. | |||||||
| > > |
Alright, enough of that.* | |||||||
|
As I was saying, I'm trying to figure out | ||||||||
| Line: 164 to 164 | ||||||||
|
| ||||||||
| Added: | ||||||||
| > > |
* The quest for rescue-by-parochial-school has begun early this year.
| |||||||
| -- CatherineJohnson - 04 Dec 2006 | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.41 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 74 to 74 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Their SAT scores are "above average." | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
No further info. | |||||||
| > > |
No further info.
That's a bad sign. | |||||||
|
| ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
Alright, enough of that for the moment. | |||||||
| > > |
Alright, enough of that. | |||||||
|
As I was saying, I'm trying to figure out | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.40 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 18 to 18 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The goal is to make cuts. Figure out who doesn't "belong." | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
I've been hearing that word for many, many years here in Irvington. belong | |||||||
| > > |
I've been hearing that word for many, many years here in Irvington. belong | |||||||
| Last year an Irvington administrator told me that "Irvington is the most heavily tracked district I've ever seen." | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.39 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 32 to 32 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
Plan A has to be figuring out whether there is or is not a decent Catholic boys' school somewhere in Westchester County. At this point I think even Ed would be on board for packing Christopher off to the Jesuits for the next few years. (He's come a long way, baby.) | |||||||
| > > |
Plan A has to be figuring out whether there is or is not a decent Catholic boys' school somewhere in Westchester County. At this point I think even Ed would be on board for packing Christopher off to the Jesuits for the next few years. | |||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
Christopher claims there's a good one in White Plains, so I'll look into it. | |||||||
| > > |
(He's come a long way, baby.)
Christian claims there's a good one in White Plains, so I'll look into it. | |||||||
|
[pause] | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.38 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.37 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 8 to 8 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Now that we have across-the-board | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
The "challenge" here in Irvington is that we have a spiral curriculum in math and ELA classes that assign novels two years below grade level. This results in predictable not-great achievement, at which point we throw the kids into ferocious competition and tracking for accelerated and Honors classes. | |||||||
| > > |
The "challenge" here in Irvington is that we have a spiral curriculum in math and ELA classes that assign novels two years below grade level. This results in predictable not-great achievement by the end of middle school, at which point we throw the kids into ferocious competition and tracking for accelerated and Honors classes. | |||||||
| Only the children who "belong" in Honors and/or accelerated courses gain admission, and the admissions process is grueling. Students have to write essays; parents have to sign letters saying they know their kids are applying to Honors and giving their OK. | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.36 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.35 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 10 to 10 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The "challenge" here in Irvington is that we have a spiral curriculum in math and ELA classes that assign novels two years below grade level. This results in predictable not-great achievement, at which point we throw the kids into ferocious competition and tracking for accelerated and Honors classes. | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
Only the children who "belong" in Honors and/or accelerated courses gain admission, and the admissions process is grueling. Students have to write essays; parents have to sign letters saying they know their kids are applying to Honors and OKing the process. | |||||||
| > > |
Only the children who "belong" in Honors and/or accelerated courses gain admission, and the admissions process is grueling. Students have to write essays; parents have to sign letters saying they know their kids are applying to Honors and giving their OK. | |||||||
| No effort is made to recruit students into the Honors track. | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.34 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 10 to 10 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The "challenge" here in Irvington is that we have a spiral curriculum in math and ELA classes that assign novels two years below grade level. This results in predictable not-great achievement, at which point we throw the kids into ferocious competition and tracking for accelerated and Honors classes. | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
Only the children who "belong" in Honors and/or accelerated courses gain admission - and the admissions process is grueling. Students have to write essays; parents have to sign letters saying they know their kids are applying to Honors and OKing the process. | |||||||
| > > |
Only the children who "belong" in Honors and/or accelerated courses gain admission, and the admissions process is grueling. Students have to write essays; parents have to sign letters saying they know their kids are applying to Honors and OKing the process. | |||||||
| No effort is made to recruit students into the Honors track. | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.33 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 8 to 8 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Now that we have across-the-board | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
The "challenge" here in Irvington is that we have a spiral curriculum in math and ELA classes that assign novels two years below reading level. This results in predictable not-great achievement, at which point we throw the kids into ferocious competition and tracking for accelerated and Honors classes. | |||||||
| > > |
The "challenge" here in Irvington is that we have a spiral curriculum in math and ELA classes that assign novels two years below grade level. This results in predictable not-great achievement, at which point we throw the kids into ferocious competition and tracking for accelerated and Honors classes. | |||||||
| Only the children who "belong" in Honors and/or accelerated courses gain admission - and the admissions process is grueling. Students have to write essays; parents have to sign letters saying they know their kids are applying to Honors and OKing the process. | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.32 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 143 to 143 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| So....I'm going to do what my mother did. | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
Keep Christopher well-stocked in the best books I can find, buy him anything he's remotely interested in reading, and hope for the best. | |||||||
| > > |
Keep Christopher well-stocked in the best books I can find, buy him anything he's remotely interested in reading, and hope for the best. I may also try to bribe the school into giving him an assigned reading list filled with books at his actual reading level. | |||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.31 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 141 to 141 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The one Bayesian prior I have to hope is gold in the bank is me: as far as I can tell, I owe my own recentered Verbal 790 not to anything my schools did, but to the fact that I was a natural born bookworm. I read all the time, from age 5 on. I read whatever I wanted to read, and what I wanted to read was fiction up 'til high school when I started reading the Great Works of authors like A.S. Neill, John Holt, and Eldridge Cleaver. | ||||||||
| Added: | ||||||||
| > > |
So....I'm going to do what my mother did. Keep Christopher well-stocked in the best books I can find, buy him anything he's remotely interested in reading, and hope for the best. | |||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.30 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 137 to 137 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
This is one of those dilemmas where I don't have time to figure it all out; I am going to have to rely on Bayesian priors and, furthermore, I am going to have to assume that I have some Bayesian priors worth listening to. | |||||||
| > > |
This is one of those dilemmas where I don't have time to figure it all out; I'm going to have to rely on Bayesian priors and, furthermore, I am going to have to assume that I have some Bayesian priors worth listening to. | |||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
The one Bayesian prior that I have to hope is gold in the bank is me: as far as I can tell, I owe my own recentered Verbal 790 to my own completely self-selected program of reading for pleasure from the age of 5 on. | |||||||
| > > |
The one Bayesian prior I have to hope is gold in the bank is me: as far as I can tell, I owe my own recentered Verbal 790 not to anything my schools did, but to the fact that I was a natural born bookworm. I read all the time, from age 5 on. I read whatever I wanted to read, and what I wanted to read was fiction up 'til high school when I started reading the Great Works of authors like A.S. Neill, John Holt, and Eldridge Cleaver. | |||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.29 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 139 to 139 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
This is one of those dilemmas where I don't have time to figure it all out; I am going to have to rely on Bayesian priors and, furthermore, I am going to have to assume that I have some Bayesian priors worth listening to. | ||||||||
| Added: | ||||||||
| > > |
The one Bayesian prior that I have to hope is gold in the bank is me: as far as I can tell, I owe my own recentered Verbal 790 to my own completely self-selected program of reading for pleasure from the age of 5 on. | |||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.28 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 86 to 86 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Elaine McEwan's book Raising Reading Achievement in Middle and High Schools: Five Simple-to-Follow Strategies arrived with depressing news: just having your kids read books doesn't seem to be enough. | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
I haven't finished reading that chapter, but Elaine said she was depressed by the research on this, so naturally I became depressed, too. (Being sick in bed with the flu helped.) | |||||||
| > > |
I haven't finished reading that chapter, but Elaine said she was depressed by the research on this, so naturally I became depressed, too. Being sick in bed with the flu helped. | |||||||
| Elaine (we're on a first name basis at this point, Elaine & me) thinks students have to be "held accountable" for their reading - i.e. they have to do something, such as writing a summary, to show they not only read the thing, they understood it - and they have to continually read more complicated books. | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.27 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 137 to 137 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
This is one of those dilemmas where I don't have time to figure it all out; I am going to have to rely on Bayesian priors and, furthermore, I am going to have to assume that I have some Bayesian priors worth listening to. | |||||||
| > > |
This is one of those dilemmas where I don't have time to figure it all out; I am going to have to rely on Bayesian priors and, furthermore, I am going to have to assume that I have some Bayesian priors worth listening to. | |||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.26 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 130 to 130 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| "the Lexile Framework should never be the only factor considered when selecting a book" (p. 49). | ||||||||
| Deleted: | ||||||||
| < < |
Stenner feels, however, that the lexile measure of a book, "should be the first step in the book selection process" (Stenner et. al. 2001, p. 48). This suggests that the reader can only make a choice within a certain lexile level or range. Elsewhere, Stenner takes a position that appears to be opposed to readers reading above and below their level: "As the reader improves, new titles with higher text measures can be chosen to match the growing person measure, thus keeping the comprehension rate at the chosen level. In essence, we need to locate a reader's 'edge' and then systematically expose the reader to text that plays on that edge..." (Stenner, 1996, p. 20). | |||||||
|
source: | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
The Lexile Framework: The Controversy Continues | |||||||
| > > |
The Lexile Framework: The Controversy Continues | |||||||
| Added: | ||||||||
| > > |
This is one of those dilemmas where I don't have time to figure it all out; I am going to have to rely on Bayesian priors and, furthermore, I am going to have to assume that I have some Bayesian priors worth listening to. | |||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.25 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 112 to 112 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
The use of systems such as the Lexile Framework can limit choices. Studies show that children often select books both above and below their current reading level, | |||||||
| > > |
Studies show that children often select books both above and below their current reading level, | |||||||
| and this is a good thing. Children can often understand large sections of books that are "too hard" because of their interest in and knowledge of the topic,2 and "easy" books often provide valuable background in a new genre that encourages | ||||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.24 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 108 to 108 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
So I cruised the readability stuff....and got out my book on summarizing and finally committed to reading the whole thing.... | |||||||
| > > |
So I cruised the readability stuff....and got out my book on summarizing and finally committed to reading the whole thing....and in waking moments I was trying to figure out how, exactly, I'm going to make sure Christopher reads progressively more challenging material AND is "held accountable," by me, for his progressively more challenging reading I came across the following passage: | |||||||
| Added: | ||||||||
| > > |
The use of systems such as the Lexile Framework can limit choices. Studies show that children often select books both above and below their current reading level, and this is a good thing. Children can often understand large sections of books that are "too hard" because of their interest in and knowledge of the topic,2 and "easy" books often provide valuable background in a new genre that encourages subsequent reading and makes it more comprehensible (Carter, 2000). Left on their own, children engage in a "back and forth movement" between easy and hard books, reading both below and above their current reading levels (Fresch, 1995). In addition, children gradually read books that are more challenging, without the use of reading levels (Krashen, 2001a). The back and forth movement is actually a sine wave that gradually moves upward. Stenner appears to agree. in one Metametrics brochure ("The 3 Rs': Using the Lexile Framework"), it states that "one strategy that works well is to have students read an easier text on the same subject in order to provide some background knowledge and vocabulary" (p. 3). And Stenner, Burdick, Sanford and Burdick (2001) advise that "the Lexile Framework should never be the only factor considered when selecting a book" (p. 49). Stenner feels, however, that the lexile measure of a book, "should be the first step in the book selection process" (Stenner et. al. 2001, p. 48). This suggests that the reader can only make a choice within a certain lexile level or range. Elsewhere, Stenner takes a position that appears to be opposed to readers reading above and below their level: "As the reader improves, new titles with higher text measures can be chosen to match the growing person measure, thus keeping the comprehension rate at the chosen level. In essence, we need to locate a reader's 'edge' and then systematically expose the reader to text that plays on that edge..." (Stenner, 1996, p. 20). source: | |||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.23 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 104 to 104 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| I gave it to Christopher and discovered that his "reading for pleasure" level is grade 6; his "instructional" level is grade 7. I suspect he's going to come out higher than that on the ITBS, but the San Diego was helpful. The two words Christopher couldn't read were science vocabulary: "relativity" (grade 6) and "capillary" (grade 7). | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
If you're going to use it with your own child, use this link. | |||||||
| > > |
If you're going to use it with your own child, use this link. So I cruised the readability stuff....and got out my book on summarizing and finally committed to reading the whole thing.... | |||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.22 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 104 to 104 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| I gave it to Christopher and discovered that his "reading for pleasure" level is grade 6; his "instructional" level is grade 7. I suspect he's going to come out higher than that on the ITBS, but the San Diego was helpful. The two words Christopher couldn't read were science vocabulary: "relativity" (grade 6) and "capillary" (grade 7). | ||||||||
| Added: | ||||||||
| > > |
If you're going to use it with your own child, use this link. | |||||||
| <<O>> Difference Topic HowChildrenReadLogPage (r1.21 - 04 Dec 2006 - CatherineJohnson) |
| ||||||||
| Line: 8 to 8 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Now that we have across-the-board | ||||||||
| Changed: | ||||||||
| < < |
The "challenge" here in Irvington is that we not only have a spiral curriculum in math and ELA classes that assign novels two years below reading level. | |||||||
| > > |
The "challenge" here in Irvington is that we have a spiral curriculum in math and ELA classes that assign novels two years below reading level. This results in predictable not-great achievement, at which point we throw the kids into ferocious competition and tracking for accelerated and Honors classes.
Only the children who "belong" in Honors and/or accelerated courses gain admission - and the admissions process is grueling. Students have to write essays; parents have to sign letters saying they know their kids are applying to Honors and OKing the process.
No effort is made to recruit students into the Honors track.
Ever.
The goal is to make cuts. Figure out who doesn't "belong."
I've been hearing that word for many, many years here in Irvington. belong
Last year an Irvington administrator told me that "Irvington is the most heavily tracked district I've ever seen."
So that's the dilemma.
We're paying $20,000 a year in property taxes for Darwinian gatekeeping.
| |||||||
| Plan A has to be figuring out whether there is or is not a decent Catholic boys' school somewhere in Westchester County. At this point I think even Ed would be on board for packing Christopher off to the Jesuits for the next few years. (He's come a long way, baby.) | ||||||||